Case: Gabriel Gonzalez v. Kellogg Partners, H.R.M. Realty Inc. and Ayco Development
Corp. General Partners d.ba. Palmentto Lakes Realty Associates LTD.
Case No: 97-23938 CA 25, Miami-Dade Circuit Court
Judge: Fredricka Smith
Trial Date: Oct. 5, 2004
Filing date: Oct. 21, 1997
Plaintiff attorneys: Daren Stabinski of
Stabinski & Funt Miami; Ronald D. Rodman and Daniel Gilfarb of Friedman Rodman & Frank,
Miami; and Pamela Beckham of Beckham & Beckham, North Miami Beach
Defense attorney: Michael Kraft and Michael Wolensky of Conroy Simberg Ganon Krevans &
Details: On July 10, 1995, Gabriel Gonzalez, 40, sustained several severe injuries
after he fell 20 feet through the roof of a Miami warehouse. His fall
was broken by an air-conditioning duct . . .
Read more here
Gonzalez, a roofer employed by Anchor Roofing, was a member of a crew
that was removing the building’s old roof when he stepped on a wooden
board covering a hole and plunged to the ground. Gonzalez suffered a fractured
ankle, a fracture shoulder, herniated discs, a knee sprain, dizziness,
blurriness and headaches.
The fractures required surgery and Gonzalez also needed neurological treatment.
He sued the New York-based managers of the warehouse for medical expenses
and lost wages.
Plaintiff’s case: Attorneys for Gonzalez argued that the roof had
been tarred over, hiding the boarded up hole from view. Stabinski said
that Anchor was never given access to the inside of the warehouse, where
the hole, which was possibly a skylight, would have been visible.
“The evidence was that from the inside of the unit you could see
the skylight. Whoever had done this [boarded up the hole] had tarred the
whole thing over so you wouldn’t know it was there,” Stabinski said.
Stabinski argued that the property management companies should have known
about the hole since at the time of the accident they had owned the warehouse
for 13 years. The warehouse was three years old at the time Palmetto Lake
Realty purchased it.
Defendants’ case: Kraft did not respond to a phone message seeking
comment. Stabinski said that the management companies argued that they
did not know about the hole in the roof.
The defense also argued that the accident was the roofing company’s
fault, since other employees knew about the hole’s existence for
up to 15 minutes before the accident but failed to inform Gonzalez.
The defense also put one of Gonzalez’s supervisors on the stand,
who testified that the board had been removed when Gonzalez fell.
Outcome: On Oct. 5, a jury found that Palmetto Lakes Realty and its subsidiaries
were 70 percent liable for Gonzalez’s injuries. The jury found Gonzalez
10 percent liable and assigned 20 percent of the liability to Anchor Roofing.
Gonzalez was awarded $159,000 in past medical expenses $80,000 in lost
earnings, $400,000 in future medical expenses, $300,000 for the past damages.
After accounting for Gonzalez’s liability, a judgment for $1.24
million was entered on Oct .14.